Leader Six Newsroom

October 25th, 2016

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times

From Combat to Community

"Recovery happens only in community.”
Jonathan Shay

During a military career, many things are monitored and measured. Service members become familiar with routine things like physical fitness tests, training evaluations, and performance assessments, just to name a few. Despite their regularity, there is still room for revelation.

During a late-career, hearing “tune-up,” I sat in a padded sound-proof booth. It was a call-and-response-style test: the technician would send a noise into the booth, and if I could hear it, I would press the button on a handheld clicker. When I came out and was gathering my things to leave, the technician asked, “General, can I share an experience I’ve been encountering with soldiers who had just returned from combat deployments?”

She described getting the test set up and sending them into the booth. The tests would begin and after some back and forth of the buzz and response sequence, the responses would stop. Confused, the technician went over to the booth and found these service members sitting inside crying. She’d asked them what was wrong, and, physically shaken, they each explained that being alone in a room that essentially shut the world off had opened the doors to memories and feelings about their combat experiences that had, until that moment, been held tightly beneath the surface. She encouraged them to seek medical care, but many refused because they feared therapy’s stigma would negatively affect their leadership capability and career.

A routine audio examination had revealed two things: how powerfully military culture influences service members’ behavior and, in the “new normal” of near continuous warfare and family disruption, there were now—in addition to physical injury—immeasurable psychological and emotional alarms ringing louder than ever. These would take innovative approaches to address.

Among those innovations is the arts. We’ve been learning more and more about the positive impact of the arts to trauma-healing. Since 2011, the National Endowment for the Arts and the Department of Defense have supported art therapy as part of patient-centered care for troops diagnosed with traumatic brain injury and other psychological health conditions at two medical treatment facilities: NICoE Walter Reed National Military Medical Center and at the NICoE Intrepid Spirit-1, Fort Belvoir in Virginia.

And it’s working. In a survey at the NICoE Walter Reed, 85 percent of military patients said art therapy was helpful to their healing. In addition, military patients consistently rated art therapy among the top four treatments out of more than 40 health interventions.

One overarching value of the Creative Forces program is that it personifies [Jonathan] Shay’s notion that healing occurs within community. The idea of “community” is a dominate attribute of military culture. When one hears a service member, apprehensive about transitioning or retiring from military service, say, “It’s time to return to the ‘real world’,” the term “real world” connotes a feeling that civilian society is somehow alien to their military experience. In an all-volunteer military, where only 0.4 percent of the American population serves, this critical aspect of military culture is not readily discernible by fellow citizens.

The military and arts communities can help each other foster connection, healing, and creativity by leveraging the “community” component. This leveraging also increases the program’s effectiveness, success, and sustainability.

Creative Forces, with its focus on the signature wounds of war and investment in building the evidence that proves the value of the arts across the spectrum of military need, has the potential to raise visibility of other programs and network them in a way that makes them accessible to a wider audience. In military terms, it’s a force multiplier to the existing efforts by artists, arts organizations, local art agencies, schools, businesses, and the military community. It is a means to collaborate for common health and wellness outcomes and with broader efforts like the National Initiative for Arts and Health in the Military (NIAHM).

Creative Forces fosters grassroots arts and military cultural change that enables our service members to transition from combat to community with the knowledge that when they hit a buzzer, there’s someone outside the sound booth who hears them loud and clear.



  • “In Honor of Their Service, the Arts Answer the Call” More
  • “Saving Haiti’s Heritage; “Mobilizing the Military” Chapter 4, pp 57 - Cultural Recovery after the Earthquake.” More
  • General tells Congress that Strong Arts funding Could Promote Military and Diplomatic Goals More


  • House Appropriations Subcommittee on Interior testimony in support of the National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) and service member benefits from arts in healing. More
  • Service Episode, Crafts In America More


  • It was the best of times,... More
  • The Power for Successive... More
  • From Combat to Community,...More